1995 ninetales pokemon card holographic New choose 1 of them and switch it with the Defending Pokémon Light Ninetales 050 - 1st

Im not normally one for dice rolling, but Ill take those odds to get extra rolls

Blasphemous Act and Damnation off the top of my head are solid

Flying as a mechanic went from this card cant be blocked except by other creatures with flying to this card cant be blocked except by other creatures with flying or reach. Portal: Three Kingdoms being a one-off starter set, didnt have any creatures specifically designed to counter horsemanship

You might need to sift through to find what youre looking for, but for those willing to spend time instead of money, buying cheap Pokmon cards can be a very cost-effective way of building up your library